Customer Stories:

Enhancing Support for Western Illinois University through Innovative Direct Mail

Who:

Tim Hallinan, Director of Annual Giving at the Western Illinois University Foundation, oversees all facets of the Annual Giving Program, which includes reaching out to a broad audience of over 130,000 alumni, parents, and friends. The primary goal is to secure annual support for the academic programs and scholarships at Western Illinois University.

The Challenge:

A central challenge was to introduce the Parent and Family Association as a giving opportunity to parents and family members of WIU students. The primary objective was to garner support for the Student Emergency Fund and expand the donor base. Additionally, the campaign aimed to educate parents and family members about the existence of the fund and its impact.

Why evertrue:

Pledgemine by EverTrue was chosen as the platform for a direct mail initiative to reach parents and family members, marking a departure from WIU’s previous outreach methods. It offered an effective means of educating the target audience about the Student Emergency Fund, as well as the opportunity to present a student’s story in greater detail than a phone call alone could provide. Moreover, Pledgemine facilitated the collection of address updates.

The results:

The campaign yielded a positive response rate of approximately 5%, indicating the effectiveness of the acquisition mailing. Importantly, it proved to be not only cost-effective but profitable. It had a notable impact on the Phonathon results, as total Phonathon gifts from sophomore parents were generally 25% higher compared to parents of other class years. These results paved the way for the expansion of Student Emergency Fund outreach in the following year.

The Full Story

The Annual Giving Program at WIU had traditionally employed a combination of methods, including direct mail, Phonathon, and electronic communications, to reach out to its wide audience. The Parents appeal campaign marked a significant departure from previous outreach efforts. Western Illinois University had primarily relied on the Phonathon program to connect with parents, limiting its engagement with this crucial segment of the donor base. This innovative direct mail initiative was conceived to bridge that gap and provide a more effective way of reaching parents and family members.

Objectives of the Campaign

The campaign had two primary objectives. Firstly, it aimed to introduce the Parent and Family Association as a giving opportunity for parents to support the Student Emergency Fund. This fund was designed to provide support to students in times of crisis. Secondly, the campaign sought to expand the donor base for the university.

Choosing the Right Format

The direct mail format was chosen as the ideal way to educate parents and family members about the Student Emergency Fund and introduce them to a student who had benefited from it. This format allowed for a more personal and detailed presentation of the student’s story than a simple phone call could achieve.

Segmentation as a Strategy

The campaign was sent to a test population of about 1,000 parents and family members of sophomore students, representing less than 1% of the university’s database. This served as a trial run to assess the feasibility of expanded direct mail outreach in the future. The positive results have sparked optimism for future campaigns.

Achieving the Objectives

The campaign yielded impressive results. The response rate was approximately 5%, making it a profitable acquisition mailing. Additionally, it proved to be an effective pre-call piece, as Phonathon callers referenced it in their follow-up calls. As a result, conversations about the impact of the fund were more substantial compared to cold calls. The data showed that total Phonathon gifts from sophomore parents were generally 25% higher than parents of other class years.

Cost-Effective and Insightful

One of the most striking aspects of this campaign was its cost-effectiveness. Despite being budget-friendly, it maintained quality and personalization. The success of the Parents appeal provided valuable insights and shaped the scope of parent and family direct mail outreach for the following year. The revenue results were impressive, and the knowledge gained from this campaign will guide future outreach endeavors.

The campaign’s success was achieved without compromising quality or personalization. Furthermore, it offered valuable insights that informed the scope of parent and family direct mail outreach for the subsequent year. The revenue results were promising, and the campaign provided valuable guidance for future outreach efforts. It underlined the potential for continued success in engaging parents and family members in supporting the Student Emergency Fund.

"Our response rate is currently at about 5%, so this campaign has proved to be an acquisition mailing that resulted in a profit. We found this solution to be an effective pre-call piece as well. Our Phonathon callers referenced the piece in their follow-up phone call, which led to a more in-depth conversation about the impact of the fund"